Bad Asian!
I've got a myspace profile because I'm such a fifteen year old high school student, and I was reading one of the bulletins that someone posted. It was a letter from Kevin Nadal, a Filipino Performance Artist/Activist, recounting the horrible and inexcusable attack on Filipinos everywhere and demanding an apology from ABC and the creators of Desperate Housewives.
Here is a link to the post: racist on desperate housewives
In a hospital scene, Teri Hatcher's character asks: "Can I just check those diplomas because I just want to make sure that they are not from some med school in the Philippines."
Kevin was outraged by this derogatory remark and claims that it's hateful and all Filipinos should band together to make sure that no one ever talks shit about Filipinos on mainstream television ever again. I told all of this to one of my friends who is a gay Filipino and that I thought that what Teri Hatcher's character said was actually kind of funny to me. He immediately told me that I should be ashamed of myself for hating my heritage and that he couldn't believe that I was such a "bad Asian."
A bad Asian? I laughed at a line from Desperate Housewives, for fuck's sake. All she said was that she wanted to make sure that the doctor's didn't graduate from a medical school in the Philippines. It's not like she said that Filipinos are dirty, baby-blood-drinking, Ann Coulter supporting, mouth-breathing, dog eating, fresh off the boat wastes of skin.
Sure, medical schools in the Philippines are okay (my cousin is attending one at the moment), but they're not the best. Wouldn't you want THE BEST when it came to your medical treatment? The economy in the Philippine Islands (which I will now be referring to as the PI) is really shitty and a lot of the schools are not getting the financial support they need to raise the quality of the programs there.
On a totally unrelated note that I'm probably going to get a lot of negative e-mails about but I still feel is important to add to this entry because I'm a tad bit superficial, the medical student uniforms are ugly. My aunt showed me a picture of my cousin in his uniform and he looked like he was a member of Nurse Ratched's goon squad getting ready to pounce on Jack Nicholson. Google it.
Kevin Nadal also mentioned that this remark should be held in the same regard as the ones made by Michael Richards, Isaiah Washington, and Rosie O'Donnell. I'm not black, but I am gay and Asian so I can only respond to Isaiah's and Rosie's comments. I really didn't care. I didn't stand up and march on Washington just because someone called someone else a fag or made the "ching chong" language mock. Frankly, I feel that there are more important things to get riled up about and that people need to chill the fuck out.
Let's not forget that these are actors and television presenters making these comments, not important people like teachers or employers. Why should I be so concerned when someone who I've never met and who has no influence on my life calls someone a bad name?
I was watching Alec Mapa's comedy special on Logo last night and he is a gay Filipino actor/comedian (some of you know him as Suzuki from Ugly Betty) and 90% of his stand up act was stereotypical jokes about Filipinos. If people are so up in arms about someone making a stereotypical comment about Filipinos on Desperate Housewives, then where is the online petition against Alec Mapa? There is no such petition at this time because people think that if a Filipino is making fun of Filipinos, then it's okay. If you get all preachy to me about laughing at Desperate Housewives but turn around and laugh when Alec Mapa jokes about Filipinos believing in vampires (in a heavy Filipino accent), then you need to seriously re-examine your position. Most people call it a double standard. I call it bullshit. I personally think that Alec Mapa is hilarious and only mentioned him in this manner to prove a point.
I'm not a bad Asian. I like rice. I drove a Honda. I take my shoes off when I go inside someone else's home. All kidding aside, people need to take a step back and calm down. Getting your fellow Filipinos all riled up about some stupid joke about your race is not the way to strengthen the image of Filipinos in America. Establishing yourself as a talented actor/comedian like Alec Mapa is the way. Being the first Filipino Eponine on Broadway like Lea Salonga is the way. Having the courage to blog out and speak your mind against thousands of Filipinos who read someone's myspace bulletin at the risk of never being invited to a Filipino party where they serve really good lumpia is the way.


6 Comments:
It's funny how people take their coincidental affiliations, and make them the crux of their identity. It allows them to get all collectivist...
I think it's good you're standing up against such irrational collectivist behavior.
October 03, 2007 2:09 PM
If that bit of dialogue was written for some show in Timbuktu, I don't think it would have gotten such a strong reaction. But this is the Hollywood cultural machine - with an audience of millions all over the world.
I don't think the insinuation was that Philippine med schools were mediocre. The writer implied incompetence. The irony is that so many Filipinos are already working for the US health industry, so you can see how people might be upset. Its their reputation and livelihood at risk. The ramifications are also economic - it is quite well known among the Diaspora how remittances provide social the safety-net the Philippine public sector is unable (indeed unwilling) to provide.
So you see, it isn't just a matter of being too sensitive, or as the previous commenter has said, about the irrationality of being "collectivist" (nothing wrong with that in my opinion).
October 03, 2007 11:42 PM
This is just another instance of multiculturalism gone berserk! And the statement was even a joke. I'm in full favor of outright harshly criticizing cultural norms and behaviors that are objectively bad, harmful, foolish, or detrimental... like the recent mass worship of a 15kg rock in India.
Btw, when I lived in Chicago, I was very good friends with a filipino. He gave me such a great experience of his culture, the food, the karaoke craze, the fafafine's! :)
That last is truly an interesting topic for anthropological study, especially given that the Philippines is such a conservative Catholic society.
October 04, 2007 9:55 PM
If you read some of the comments after the guys email who was so angry with desperate housewives, most people said it was simply a joke , as it was. Anyone who knows or loves anyone from PI , knows they are truly a gift to this world. It was only a joke.
October 05, 2007 6:38 AM
You know...It would be nice if everyone could put as much energy into something more important than bitching about a stupid line in a tv sitcom. It was a joke...plain and simple and I agree with Richie...It was funny.
Get over it people...The world is a mess...People are starving, genocide is rampant and the President is torchuring and murdering people.
October 05, 2007 10:08 AM
http://www.petitiononline.com/NadalAss/petition.html
Please sign my petition! Show everyone that not all Fil-Ams are humorless twats like Kevin Nadal. He is NOT the voice of the Fil-Am community, much less the Fil-Am medical community.
The show is SATIRE. The show is FICTIONAL. The line was a JOKE.
It's DESPERATE HOUSEWIVES, not the CONSTITUTION.
It'S TERI HATCHER, not (insert name of some you think is more credible --and
less annoying-- than Teri Hatcher here).
Protesting/petitioning Fil-Ams (and to anybody else giving this thing the time
of day): GET OVER YOURSELVES.
(Please place tongue firmly in cheek before signing.)
October 05, 2007 7:15 PM
Post a Comment
Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]
<< Home